There is ONE major difference between USMLE Step 2 CK and USMLE Step 3, and it’s not the CCS.
It’s in how both exams are scored.
Step 3 is scored more robustly.
If you sit for USMLE Step 2 CK and USMLE Step 3 with the same level of knowledge and preparation, you will score about 20 points lower on USMLE Step 3. This has been proven time and time again. Just read students USMLE Step 3 experience on Reddit, and you’ll see this difference in scoring almost consistently.
So, how does this affect me?
Well, since the NBME does not have great assessment exams for USMLE Step 3, and like many students you probably haven’t used NBME’s USMLE Step 2 CK’s assessments exams, you’re better off using NBME’s 9 -14 (thought to be for USMLE Step 2 CK) to assess your readiness for USMLE Step 3. Just don’t forget to subtract the 20 points.
So if you score 225 on NBME 9, that means that your predicted Step 3 score is 205.
If you scored 240 on NBME 12, then your predicted Step 3 score is 220.
If you just learned that you scored 250 on your USMLE Step 2 CK, and take Step 3 with the same medical knowledge, you will score close to 230.
Otherwise, USMLE Step 2 CK and USMLE Step 3 are more or less the same.
Sure, Step 3 has the CCS portion, and is a two day exam. But when it comes to the bulk of the exam – the MCQ portion, it’s the same. Want evidence? Read on…
If you look at the “content outline specifications” straight out of the USMLE.org website for Step 2 CK and Step 3, they are strikingly similar.
Both exams cover major organ systems like cardiovascular, respiratory, and gastrointestinal. The difference lies in weight distribution:
• Step 3 places a greater emphasis on biostatistics and public health (11–13% vs. Step 2 CK’s 3–5%).
• Clinical decision-making and management are prioritized, which means the test focuses less on diagnosis and more on what to do next.
Otherwise, the MCQ portion of Step 3 is essentially an extension of Step 2 CK. If you’ve prepared well for Step 2 CK, your existing knowledge will carry you through most of Step 3.
What About the CCS?
The CCS (Computer-based Case Simulations) portion is unique to Step 3 and requires specific preparation. While the MCQs rely on Step 2 CK-level knowledge, the CCS evaluates your ability to apply that knowledge in real-time, simulated scenarios. Fortunately, with some practice on the CCS software and a clear strategy for managing cases, you can master this section without much difficulty.
Who Will Struggle Most with Step 3?
If you scored above 220 on Step 2 CK [the higher the better, obviously], you’re likely to pass Step 3 as long as you understand the CCS software and maintain the same level of preparation.
However, if you scored below 220 on Step 2 CK and are struggling to pass Step 3, the issue may lie in your test-taking skills, not necessarily your medical knowledge. Hitting a passing score on Step 3 demands a higher level of clinical reasoning to make up for the robust scoring algorithm for USMLE Step 3, and simply memorizing tables or milking Q banks dry won’t be enough. You’ll need to refine how you approach questions, focusing on analyzing clinical scenarios, “guessing” correctly, and selecting the most appropriate next steps.
Bridging the Gap
I built my website and course because misinformation about Step 3 leaves many students and residents struggling unnecessarily. If you’ve been frustrated by vague advice or feel stuck, know that you’re not alone. My USMLE TACTICS Course is designed to help students improve their test-taking skills, gain clarity, and confidently pass Step 3.
______________________
Disclaimer: The images and content referenced on this website from USMLE.org are used solely for informational and educational purposes. All copyrights and trademarks are the property of their respective owners, including USMLE.org and the National Board of Medical Examiners (NBME). This website is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or approved by USMLE.org, NBME, or any of their associated organizations. The inclusion of any material does not imply any form of association or endorsement, and all efforts have been made to credit the original sources. If you are the copyright holder of any material used here and believe it has been used improperly or without appropriate permission, please contact us immediately for resolution.
3/21/2025